Sunday, July 12, 2015

Daat Torah; The Mind (or Opinion) of Torah part 5


A crucial idea in the debate over Daat Torah is a Talmudic statement that in order to truly understand the Torah, we must inculcate "Emunat Chachamim". This is usually translated as "Faith in the Sages". How is this to be understood? The Torah commands us (Deuteronomy 17:8-13) to follow the instructions of the sages of the Sanhedrin. The Torah even stipulates a death penalty for those who do not accept their rulings. But what happens after the demise of the Sanhedrin, which occurred around the year 400?? RAMBAM rules that, after that, there is no universal rabbinic authority, other than a rabbi chosen by a community, for that community only. Other than that, we listen to what rabbis have to say, and hold their words up to the scrutiny of earlier sources, as well as logic. Rashi, expressing the view of most Ashkenazi rabbis at that time (11th century) posits that all great sages in a generation together form a sort of Sanhedrin. Their words are to be seen as binding according to Torah law. Moreover, there is a Talmudic concept of "halachah k'batrai" (the law follows the later authority). The idea here is that the later scholar has seen the words of the earlier scholars. If he has ruled against them, he surely had a good reason, even if that is not readily apparent to us. Therefore, according to this, a rabbi in 2022 can overrule a rabbi from a thousand years ago. This is a very strong concept in most Orthodox communities. Of course, this would not mean EVERY rabbi, but those who are noted for their vast knowledge and piety; the Gedolim. RAMBAM, on the other hand, states that the principle of "halachah k'batrai" only applies until about the year 400, as long as there was a Sanhedrin. After that, we go by who is most logical, and whose views conform with sources. This view is upheld in most Sepharadic communities and some Modern Orthodox. So what about "faith in the Sages"?
The fact is that the phrase probably doesn't mean that! Faith in the Sages would be translated into Hebrew as "Emunah BaChachamim". "Emunat Chachamim actually means "Faith OF the Sages"! That is, Judaism must be understood in terms of the Oral Tradition, as transmitted to us from Moses, through all the Sanhedrins and ultimately through their heirs, the Rabbis of the Talmud. It is saying that there is no other way to understand the Torah, except through the Oral Tradition The statement is NOT an automatic endorsement of the views of rabbis yet to be born. We are not to negate them, but Torah resides in sources, not personalities. A modern sage, according to this approach, is NOT an authority figure, but rather a repository of ancient treasure. We must learn, be inspired, and absorb the light of the millennia. We are not to close our minds, but open them.

Friday, July 10, 2015

Daat Torah; The Mind (or Opinion) of Torah part 4



A corollary to this idea of making one Judaism, with common, codified beliefs, is, in my opinion, a "dumbing down" of Judaism. Orthodox Judaism has always included a spectrum of approaches and understandings, albeit united by certain basic principles. While unity can be a beautiful thing, putting minds into a straight jacket is not. I would like to share several personal experiences I have had.
The first was when I was seventeen. I am not from an observant background. I was greatly helped by Chabad, a group that pioneered outreach. However, one of the doctrines of this group was to insist on a literal understanding of Talmudic legends. Some were VERY hard to accept at face value. I was experiencing a crisis of faith. I began college that year. As this was shortly before the "teshuvah movement", a baal teshuvah was seen as fairly unique. The campus rabbi asked me how I was relating to traditional Judaism. I told him that I loved it, but was having a hard time accepting the legends. He said "what are you talking about? They were never meant to be understood as anything other than allegories. RAMBAM writes this explicitly". I was puzzled. I asked the rabbi who had been teaching me. He said "NO!!! Rambam said that they had allegoric meanings besides the literal." I saw the campus rabbi the next day. With the arrogance of youth, I said "You lied to me on this point". He said "let's look into the writings of RAMBAM." This idea had never occurred to me! Sure enough, RAMBAM called those who understand them literally "fools". I confronted the rabbi who was teaching me. he said "Oy! Why did he show you that? I didn't want to confuse you." My problem was not with the stance, but with his branding it as the ONLY stance.
Fast forward fifteen years. My wife and I, with our one and a half kids, moved to a lovely New England community. We were delighted to find that there were several groups of Orthodox Jews there. Our delight didn't last long, as we discovered that the different factions were at odds, even to the extent of lawsuits. We decided to try and be on good terms with all the groups. My wife befriended a woman in one of the groups (they are still in touch forty years later). The woman asked my wife to deliver a Dvar Torah to a women's group. My wife agreed happily. A few hours later, the phone rang. It was the Rebbetzin who was in charge of the group. She told my wife "I'm afraid that you will present teachings from Rabbi Nachman. We don't want to confuse the women. I will tell you what to say". My wife declined the "help" and withdrew her offer to speak. We were on shaky terms with that faction throughout our three years in the community.
My last story is much more recent. A friend (who is also a member of this group) posted a quote from an ArtScroll publication. She found the quote troubling. I replied that I understood the subject differently from the author, and proceeded to give my interpretation of the passage under discussion. I got a PM from a colleague, taking me to task for "showing that Orthodox Rabbis disagreed with each other", as it would confuse the people. Rabbis have been disagreeing for thousands of years! (Let me stress again that I am not speaking of heretical views, but different understandings within the confines of Torah Judaism). Somehow, a new approach had emerged, accepted by the community, which shut the door on any ideas that were not in conformity with the Lithuanian Gedolim.
I love Torah. I delight in finding out how different rabbis and groups have understood it throughout the ages. Let us not mistake an artificial unity where diversity has always held sway. Torah is Truth. Truth speaks in different forms. Let us make the effort to understand what is said while respecting other understandings.

Wednesday, July 8, 2015

Daat Torah; The Mind (or Opinion) of Torah part 3


Another issue that many have with the Daat Torah idea is the fact that nearly all the recognized "Gedolim" are of the Lithuanian stream of Orthodoxy. The Jews of Lithuania (and surrounding areas) developed a system of study involving deep analytics of Talmudic texts and deriving ideas and doctrines from these texts that are not actually spelled out. Many have accepted these methods wholeheartedly. Many have not. Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, for example, considered much of this type of learning as "confusion". ("bilbulim") The method of study in most other places involved a strong effort to understand what the text is actually saying (not always easy!). The Lithuanians set up a great network of Yeshivot, which has been transported to Israel, the U.S., as well to as many other countries. The "Harvards and Yales" of Yeshivot are all Lithuanian-style. For most Orthodox Jews, this has become standard Judaism, with other Jews expected to hop on the bandwagon. But there are dissenting voices as well. Rabbinic leaders who are rooted in other traditions see this as a form of cultural imperialism. The Syrian Jewish community of New York is deeply divided between those who wish to maintain the way of life of their ancient community, and those who feel that it is essential to accept the ways of the Lithuanian Gedolm. Many Hasidic leaders also struggle to maintain their way of life and thought. Even German Jewish leaders, the cultural and religious fore-bearers of Ashkenazi Jewry, have reservations about this. Calls for "unity" often translate into "let's all be the same".
A related factor is the effects of all this on halachah. Different communities always maintained their own interpretations of halachah. But the Gedolim of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries have pushed the idea of one unified approach. In the first decade of the twentieth century, two great books of halachah appeared in Eastern Europe. One was the "Aruch HaShulchan" of Rabbi Y.M. Epstein. It is a rewriting of the Shulchan Aruch (Code of Jewish Law), but it did much more. In each area of halachah he analyses the development from the Torah, through the Talmud and later opinions. He describes how the accepted final decision was made, but then analyses whether that conclusion is correct. He often jettisons the common practice for another one, more firmly based on sources and logic. The Aruch HaShulchan became the standard halachic work in Yeshivot until about 1950. The second work to appear simultaneously is the Mishnah Berurah of Rabbi Y.M. Kagan, known as the Chafetz Chaim. The Chafetz Chaim had made his reputation primarily as an ethicist. The Mishnah Berurah is based on the first part of the Shulchan Aruch, only (dealing with daily rituals, Shabbat and Holidays). Unlike the Aruch HaShulcahn, its primary goal is to show how the practices of Lithuanian Judaism are completely based on sources, and is essentially the only way to understand these sources. In essence, the halachic system had ended in one definitive work; a compendium of Daat Torah. The work was hailed by some, but opposed by many. Both German and Hasidic rabbis pointed out the cultural bias. Even among the Lithuanians, most preferred the analysis of the Aruch HaShulchan over the ultra-conservative Mishnah Berurah. However, around 1950, a change occurred. Many rabbis were horrified that Orthodox Jews were changing centuries-old traditions in favor of the Aruch HaShulchan's theories. This put the common man's Judaism in danger; opening the way for considering that there might be greater truths outside the Daat Torah community. The Mishnah Berurah was substituted in virtually all Yeshivot. it has become the "gold standard", with later rabbis' opinions needing to conform. Even groups that used to oppose it have accepted it, albeit with reservations. Does this signify a culmination, or decaying of the classical halachic system? Each side has its distinguished proponents. To be continued.

Tuesday, July 7, 2015

Daat Torah; The Mind (or Opinion) of Torah part 2


The system of Daat Torah; turning to a group of men who are both learned and of the greatest integrity, would seem like it would be the best vehicle for both bringing about a consensus, and arriving at truth. Often, it has worked that way. However, there were and are pitfalls. First of all, with the rise of Hasidism in the eighteenth century, the face of Jewish leadership changed. The position of the Gadol (Rabbinic Greats) was primarily dependent on knowledge of sources and their application. The Hasidic leaders, called Rebbes rather than Rabbis, was primarily based on charisma. spirituality, and the ability to counsel people in crisis. The classical rabbi rarely dealt with these things. He was more interested in the permissible or forbidden, proper and improper doctrine. The Rebbe is interested in your hopes, fears, ambitions, hurts and disappointments. Although many Rebbes were also Rabbis, many were not; or even particularly learned. When an anti-Hasidic rabbi was informed about a statement made by a famous Hasidic Rebbe, that was apparently based on a very obscure Talmudic statement, he expressed surprise that the Rebbe had known the statement. Upon hearing this, the Rebbe replied "He's right, I didn't know the statement. I got it from where the Talmud got it!" In the U.S., the usual reality is that the community rabbi is rarely a great scholar, but more of a pastoral figure. When legal questions come up, he will usually defer to a Gadol. When I lived in Israel (1984 to 2001), I would often visit the Chief Rabbi's office. Once, his personal secretary asked me "Are you sure you are a rabbi?" I said to him "of course, Why?" He said "because you're always smiling. I never saw a rabbi smile". Yes, in most of the world, the idea of a rabbi as a friend and guide is still unknown. The American experience has, in effect, blended the traditional rabbi with the rebbe.
Herein lies a problem as well as a blessing. The community rabbi (in the U.S., more often the rabbi of a synagogue rather than an entire community) is free, for the most part, of making momentous decisions. That is for the Gadol. But that also means that decisions are made by those who don't interact with the people. The local rabbi knows all about the community's circumstances. The Gadol in the ivory tower probably doesn't. There is a lovely Hasidic story about a Rebbe who visited a Gadol. He asked the Gadol "What are the roofs in your community made of?" The Gadol answered "brick". "Too bad" said the Rebbe. "It would be better if they were made of iron". The Gadol thought the Rebbe a madman. He related the story to a follower of that Rebbe. "That's amazing" said the follower. "The Rebbe was speaking about leadership. He was saying that if there is a "fire", a spiritual or material crisis, brick leadership will be unmoved. Iron will moan and groan with the rest of the house. What a pity that the people of this community only have a brick roof".
Still another issue is if setting universal standards is such a good idea. Many areas of Jewish thought are not spelled out in Tanach or Talmud. Numerous approaches appear in the writings of later scholars. Although there may have been disagreements, there was almost always respect and tolerance for other views. With the system of Daat Torah, one view generally became the only legitimate one. Since the Gedolim were educated in Torah, with little or no secular education, a decision might reflect this ignorance. Even how things are done by the average person might be unknown to them. One example came in the 1950s, when a major Gadol issued an opinion about women using makeup on Shabbat. He ruled that makeup does, indeed, violate the prohibition of "tzove'a" (coloring, dying), but powdered makeup is OK. This has become standard Orthodox policy. One can buy "Shabbat makeup" in all colors, in powdered form. Another Gadol, far better versed in worldly matters, asked the first for his reasoning. He said "Powder is not coloring. If she walks out in the slightest breeze, it will blow right off". The second Gadol wrote "Not in the slightest breeze, and not in a hurricane". But the first Gadol is seen as one of the ultimate sources of Daat Torah. His view is still accepted, not for his view's logic (or lack thereof), but because of that Gadol's stature. Some will say that this is Daat Torah. Others would say that it is a distortion of the halachic process.
More issues will be discussed in my next post.

Sunday, July 5, 2015

Daat Torah; The Mind (or Opinion) of Torah part 1



After Talmudic times, until the late seventeenth  century, communities (and rabbis) were fairly independent. True, there were times and places where a group of cities, or even an entire country, would get together in a confederation, complete with  a central rabbinic/legislative council, and establish common practices, but these were not the norm. Occasionally, a great figure would have influence far beyond his own country, but it was up to the local rabbis to give their imprimatur to those decisions. Community councils chose the rabbis, taking their views and writings into account when deciding whether to accept him as rabbi. The standard practice in most places was that a young scholar would study for a number of years under the rabbis of his region. Upon completion of his studies (formalized in Germany in the 14th century with an official ordination),  he would ask an accepted rabbi of a community to accept him as an intern; seeing and partaking in every day rabbbinic duties and decision making. When that rabbi felt him to be ready, he would grant the young man an additional ordination. The young rabbi would then seek an appropriate community where he could serve. There was no such thing as the rabbi of a synagogue. That only came in fairly recently. The rabbi was responsible for governing the community (in tandem with the elected city council), making decisions in halachah that were binding upon everyone, deal with people's individual issues, perform marriages, divorces, and all other religious ceremonies; as well as oversee the synagogues, local schools, slaughterhouses, butcher shops, and mikvehs. There were no formal Yeshivot (Rabbinic Academies) at that time, although many students would often gather to a particularly great luminary, forming a sort of ad hoc Yeshivah around him.
Everything changed in the late 1600s. Although we have had many false Messiahs in our history, there was only one who garnered near universal acceptance, sending world Jewry into a tailspin upon his conversion to Islam in 1666. His name was Shabbetai Tzvi.  Like a great hurricane that reshapes the map of an area, the Jewish world was never the same. There was no country spared. Famous rabbis had also erred. There was a crisis of faith. Could even rabbis be trusted? (There are still some nine thousand followers of Shabbetai Tzvi in Turkey).
Among the after-effects of this debacle, a number of things changed. Jewish authority shifted away from the local city or town, in the direction of centralized Batei Din (Courts). These batei din were made up of the brightest and best scholars in the region, with the highest standards of integrity. To be sure, there were local rabbis. But more and more they deferred to the decisions and policies of the court of "Gedolim" (Great ones). Even "world class rabbbis" who were not members of a Beit Din wielded great sway over lesser rabbis This became known as the system of Daat Torah (Daas Torah in Ashkenazi pronunciation). Formal institutions grew around these central authorities, insuring that their students would be well trained in sources, and not fall victim to popular delusions, like the Shabbaetai Tzvi tragedy.The great rabbis have hearts and minds filled with Torah. Shouldn't they be the people we turn to in cases of doubt? Beyond that, it was felt that these men should be the ones to ask even on questions that were not directly religious ones. Should I go into partnership with X? Should I marry Y? These were questions that had not classically been the province of rabbis. But there could be little doubt that advice given by a true Torah scholar, with no personal connection to the situation, would likely to be far better than that given by random friends.
This system has become well rooted in most Ashkenazi Orthodox communities until this day. I have had the experience of being asked by congregations where I had applied for the position of rabbi, "when we ask you a question, who will be answering it?" In other words, which Gedolim do you follow? But this system also has its critics. Why? That will be my next post.

Friday, July 3, 2015

The Akdamut


The Shavu'ot holiday commemorates the Revelation at Sinai. We are so accustomed to hearing this story, that we are often unmoved by the most remarkable event of G-d not only communicating with Man, but with an entire Nation! On Shavu'ot morning, the Torah portion is read in which the giving of the commandments is described. In German Jewish tradition, adopted by most Ashkenazim, a remarkable hymn, the Akdamut, is recited either before the Torah reading, or, even more unusual, after the Torah reading has begun and is interrupted for this hymn. Many consider it Judaism's greatest hymn. This is a view which I share.
Akadamut is a poem in Aramaic, consisting of forty four lines, each with ten syllables, with all lines ending in the syllable "ta". It takes us from the beginning of time until the end of time.
It opens with the reader apologizing for the interruption, but he must say "a few lines" about the revelation. He starts with G-d about to create the world. The hymn proceeds to creation, the perception of the angels , the creation of Man. We are then told of Israel's observance of the Torah. But the Nations are envious. "Who is your beloved, O fair one (Israel), that for Him you are killed everywhere? Join us, and we will give you great honor!" Israel replies "What will your honor mean when G-d is revealed in Redemption, when Divine honor will cover us, while you are covered in shame?) There is a description of the redemption. The Isralites will point to G-d and say "There He is! The One we believed in and had faith in Him with a fierce conviction!" The joys of the redemption, the rebuilding of Jerusalem in precious stones, are all described with great beauty. The long awaited return of the Israelites from the lands of our dispersion is extolled. A great celebration; the culmination of History, is pictured. The reader ends with "thank you for listening. May you all be present at that celebration".
As beautiful as the Akdamut is, the context is very telling. We are about to read of the Revelation.We are being told, in essence "Stop! Think about what happened. But not only that! Sinai was the culmination of Creation. It was all leading up to this; G-d communicating to Man, and setting him on a mission! But it is also a new beginning. We are to wander, be persecuted, bear testimony to the events of Sinai for millennia to come. Despite persecution, we proclaim the Truth of G-d. Most of mankind thinks us mad. But glory awaits, as all those with false values and false gods suddenly realize their great error and experience the profoundest possible shame." Almost anticlimactically, we are told "Hope to see you there!"
Sinai was a culmination. But Sinai was a beginning. In fact, every step in life is a culmination and a beginning, if we walk in the ways of Torah. Hope to see you there!

Judaism and Women part 6



The women's movement has been the catalyst in all Jewish groups for raising difficult questions. Answers are even more difficult. Are we to allow, or even encourage, hitherto unknown practices in order to allow women on the one hand a sense of full "belonging", or on the other hand to develop new directions for uniquely feminine expressions of Judaism? Or perhaps maintain what has always been done, helping all those who feel disenfranchised to understand the framework of tradition, hoping that they will relate to it. Three years ago, a group of distinguished liberal Orthodox rabbis quit the Rabbinical Council of America over this issue. They had encouraged a re-examination of Jewish life based on the classical sources, as well as re-thinking many issues of Jewish life in a way that is different from the "standard". These rabbis saw that they, and their views, were being marginalized, and that their students were being prevented from taking part in organized Orthodoxy. Will they form a new "denomination", or will their protest force everyone to asses anew their policies? It is too soon to tell.
On the other end of the spectrum, more right wing Orthodox rabbis are defending the idea that "what has been done" is also a part of Torah, even if sourceless. As we have seen in Conservatism, a challenge to a relatively minor practice can lead to a "slippery slope", with consequences no one dreamed of. The concept of "Minhag Yisrael Torah Hi" (A Jewish custom IS Torah" is often quoted, but from where? To my knowledge it is not Talmudic, but did become an accepted principle later. Does it restrict us, or liberate us?
Another factor, which greatly disturbs me (not directly connected to the women's issue), is the "dumbing down" of Judaism for the sake of simplicity. Judaism, including Orthodox Judaism, has had numerous interpretations. If one looks at the classical Torah commentaries of the "Mikraot Gedolot" (published in 1524), many of the commentators have views so divergent that we might think that they represented different religions! Yet, there was room and respect for everyone as long as basic beliefs and practices were upheld .As Judaism came under attack from atheists and heretics, the response of many rabbis was to "circle the wagons". Judaism went on the defensive. Books were written to show how greatly different opinions actually agreed with each other. Every story, every medieval legend, became an article of faith. Like a  house of cards, pull one out, and it will all come crashing down. That was the fear.  Keep it simple, keep it unified, don't confuse the people. Nevertheless, when people begin studying on their own, and see contradictions to this "one size fits all" Orthodoxy, they are often put off by rabbis telling them "it can't mean what it says". The Sea of Torah is so very vast and all encompassing, it seems a shame to me to limit it in this way. It frightens me that books written in the last twenty years are seen as SOURCES rather than opinions. Holding different views, even views based on the teachings of great rabbis, often puts people outside the "consensus". Non-conformity is seen as a danger. It is. but so is blind conformity. Both Man and Woman are in the Image of G-d. We must seek Truth, if we sincerely seek Him.